I received a copy of this
book from HarperCollins/Harlequin US in return for an honest review.
The premise of Perfectly Undone by Jamie Raintree was great. Dr. Dylan Michels is in a long-term relationship with her doctor boyfriend Cooper. When she is turned down for a grant request and he's made partner of his pediatric practice, from the reader's point of view, things start to unravel.
While not the primary focus of the plot as Raintree presents it, I see a major part of the story to be finding the balance between work and personal life, between professional ambitions and personal goals. I see my own adult children dealing
with finding the balance between work and "life".
Throw in dealing with the loss of a sibling or a child. I can only imagine how that would impact one’s life. Different family members react differently. Dylan attempts to keep much of her internal conflicts about the loss of her sister from Cooper. And that's where the Dylan's issues spiral out of control.
Keeping internal conflicts from a partner who seems to have a much better relationship with his family reminded me of Pretending to Dance by Diane Chamberlain. Chamberlain's book had much richer characters in a much more developed plot.
Perfectly Undone was engaging enough that I finished it over two rainy days of what was kind of sort of a vacation. The quick finish made me feel
like it deserved 4 stars. However, the characters are all so one-dimensional.
Even as Dylan’s character developed, she still comes across as very flat. This is not the kind of book I’d recommend to my reader friends. Then
again, perhaps this book might appeal to a reader younger than myself. At nearly 60 years old, I don't think I'm the target demographic for this title.
Monday, November 27, 2017
Fish in a Tree
While up in New York, we took a detour to visit with our granddaughters before heading home. Who knew that our 9-year old was such an avid reader? And she's finally at the point where she's reading the type of books that as a fifth grade teacher I enjoyed reading. Her library book, Fish in a Tree by Lynda Mullaly Hunt was laying around. I picked it up to look at it and it wasn't too long before I was sucked in.
I think I was so easily caught up in the novel because this is the type of novel that I have written. (Mine is still in rough draft format, but it's similar in that both Fish in a Tree and my draft, working title Dear Learning Log are about kids who feel like they just don't fit in.)
The title Fish in a Tree comes from the following quote:
The first class read aloud of the entirety of my full-time teaching career was One Thing I'm Good At by Karen Lynn Williams. Same premise. In that book, Abby Dorinsky is the girl who believes she isn't good at anything - until circumstances prove her to be quite talented. There are lots of similarities - and differences - between the two novels. Fish in a Tree has the more fully developed plot. But the message is the same. Just because you're not good at school doesn't mean you're not good at anything. And it is possible to get better at doing the school thing.
Imagine having a learning disability that makes going to school torture. It's not like you can say, I won't go to school, I'll go to work... at 10 years old. You have to go to school. Every day is just one more opportunity for things to go horribly wrong. I've been witness to it, but I really cannot imagine what that must feel like. The kids who would benefit most from this book are kids who wouldn't be able to read it on their own. But books like this will always be needed - and need to be shared with some scaffolding to make Ally's story accessible to those who might benefit from hearing it most. All kids, whether they can read independently or not enjoy being read to, whether they say so or not.
My granddaughter was amazed that I was able to finish this book in one day without impacting the day I was spending with her. We still played several rounds of board games I can't even remember the names of, an overly long game of Monopoly Junior, did some art, watched a sappy movie and just hung out. I was hoping that she'd let me know what she thought of the book once she finished it. I wonder, has she finished it yet?
I think I was so easily caught up in the novel because this is the type of novel that I have written. (Mine is still in rough draft format, but it's similar in that both Fish in a Tree and my draft, working title Dear Learning Log are about kids who feel like they just don't fit in.)
The title Fish in a Tree comes from the following quote:
“Everybody is smart in different ways. But if you judge a fish by its ability to climb a tree, it will live its life believing it is stupid.”Ally moves from school to school and does a good job fooling her teachers into not realizing that she can't read. That is until her latest teacher goes on maternity leave and she gets a really cool substitute teacher named Mr. Daniels. Not only does he recognize what the problem is, he helps Ally to come to terms with it - and to overcome it - and she is able to accept that different doesn't always mean loser.
The first class read aloud of the entirety of my full-time teaching career was One Thing I'm Good At by Karen Lynn Williams. Same premise. In that book, Abby Dorinsky is the girl who believes she isn't good at anything - until circumstances prove her to be quite talented. There are lots of similarities - and differences - between the two novels. Fish in a Tree has the more fully developed plot. But the message is the same. Just because you're not good at school doesn't mean you're not good at anything. And it is possible to get better at doing the school thing.
Imagine having a learning disability that makes going to school torture. It's not like you can say, I won't go to school, I'll go to work... at 10 years old. You have to go to school. Every day is just one more opportunity for things to go horribly wrong. I've been witness to it, but I really cannot imagine what that must feel like. The kids who would benefit most from this book are kids who wouldn't be able to read it on their own. But books like this will always be needed - and need to be shared with some scaffolding to make Ally's story accessible to those who might benefit from hearing it most. All kids, whether they can read independently or not enjoy being read to, whether they say so or not.
My granddaughter was amazed that I was able to finish this book in one day without impacting the day I was spending with her. We still played several rounds of board games I can't even remember the names of, an overly long game of Monopoly Junior, did some art, watched a sappy movie and just hung out. I was hoping that she'd let me know what she thought of the book once she finished it. I wonder, has she finished it yet?
What Inspired Margaret Wise Brown to write Goodnight Moon?
"In the great green room. There was a telephone. And a red balloon."
Many nights of my young motherhood started with those words. "In the great green room..." Goodnight Moon, the children's classic by Margaret Wise Brown, was a favorite of my two older children and myself. I'm pretty certain that we had the whole book memorized. What a fun book.
So... when I was up in New York, struggling to read, I thought an epistolary novel (one written in the form of letters) would be easy to read, if I could find the right novel. Stumbled across Sarah Jio's "what if" novel, Goodnight June. In Goodnight June, 30-something June, a ruthless banker, inherits her great aunt's failing Seattle bookstore. She finds a pair of letters between her great aunt and Margaret Wise Brown that leads her on a scavenger hunt to find more letters and to discover the relationship between the two women.
The premise of the book was cute. The execution, not so much so. I thought I'd learn more about Margaret Wise Brown. For that, I think I need to read a biography of her (the most recent one is titled The Great Green Room by Amy Gary). There is some information available on the internet, none of which contradicts any of what I read about in Goodnight June.
I'm not a fan of romance novels, but I am a fan of book stores, especially small independent book stores, and I think that's what kept me reading Goodnight June until the end. The story was fairly predictable, much of it was extremely sappy, even more of it was unrealistic, but there were several surprises thrown in. (One surprise was the fact that Jio throws in mention of real life people - like Bill and Melinda Gates coming to her book store fundraiser. I wonder how Bill and Melinda feel about that. It really didn't seem necessary. Didn't add anything at all to the story.)
You might enjoy this book if you enjoy sappy romances. The letters in the story didn't live up to my standard. They weren't really the a large part of the writing, simply a large part of moving the plot forward. Don't expect to learn too much about Margaret Wise Brown. It will leave you with more questions than answers. I really can't give this any sort of hearty recommendation.
You might enjoy this book if you enjoy sappy romances. The letters in the story didn't live up to my standard. They weren't really the a large part of the writing, simply a large part of moving the plot forward. Don't expect to learn too much about Margaret Wise Brown. It will leave you with more questions than answers. I really can't give this any sort of hearty recommendation.
The Tao of Pooh
The Tao of Pooh by Benjamin Hoff is this month's Books & Beer Club title. It was a fairly short, fairly easy, fairly commonsense book. Explaining the concepts of Tao thru the characters of Winne the Pooh. The idea was to read the book and pick which Pooh character we're most like. I'm certainly no Pooh as I don't just take things the way they come, but I found little bits of me in many of the characters.
I finished this book on the plane ride up to New York. I plan to add to this post after the book club meeting tomorrow evening. In the meantime, would I recommend the book? I'm not sure. I think it should generate a great book club discussion, but not so sure this is the type of book I'd enjoy reading independently. One of the members of Books & Beer considers it her bible. Now that I've read it, I'd like her to explain what she means. I can guess, but I just don't feel it.
I finished this book on the plane ride up to New York. I plan to add to this post after the book club meeting tomorrow evening. In the meantime, would I recommend the book? I'm not sure. I think it should generate a great book club discussion, but not so sure this is the type of book I'd enjoy reading independently. One of the members of Books & Beer considers it her bible. Now that I've read it, I'd like her to explain what she means. I can guess, but I just don't feel it.
Trying to play catch up
It's been over a month since I last posted here. If you follow me on Facebook then you know that I was dealing with some overwhelming personal stuff. Mostly the sale of the home that has been in the family for 82 years. It's been an almost 4-year cleaning project to get us to this point. I wanted to my "time with words" to be spent writing about what I was dealing with rather than reading something else. I had no computer so pretty much, I did neither. Eventually I did get back to reading... and now I'm attempting to recreate what I've read over the past month. Apparently I don't do the best job keeping my goodreads up-to-date since I have two large spaces of time where it would appear that I wasn't reading anything. And I'm missing one book that I am certain that I read.
I'll attempt to recapture my past month as best I can, to figure out what I read, and to review what I can remember.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)